
The YMCA of the Pikes Peak Region may step in to operate six city-owned aquatic facilities in Colorado Springs.
The mayor’s office announced Wednesday that the Parks, Recreation & Cultural Services Department will present details of a proposed agreement with the YMCA during Monday’s informal City Council meeting.
“Per the proposed agreement, the City will subsidize the YMCA for any shortfall experienced at the City’s aquatic facilities. Based on proposed budgets, the subsidy is estimated at no more than $632,350 for 2012. By utilizing the remaining subsidy already budgeted for Cottonwood Creek Recreation Center, estimated at $208,000, a supplemental appropriation of $425,000 is necessary. Should revenues come in higher than budgeted, or expenses turn out to be lower than anticipated, the subsidy amount will be appropriately reduced,” according to city documents.
The council will be asked to vote on funding in support of the proposed agreement the following day.
“We are thrilled with the potential of a partnership with the YMCA of the Pikes Peak Region moving forward with City Council’s approval,” Chief of Staff Laura Neumann said in a statement.
“The City has a great history of working with the YMCA, and we optimistically look forward to being able to open our swimming pools again for the benefit of our entire community,” she said.
When the city terminated its contract with private operators Kevin and Tina Dessart, at least one council member speculated that it was because the Bach administration wanted to let the YMCA take over the pools.
Councilman Merv Bennett, who was elected last year, was the longtime CEO of the YMCA of the Pikes Peak Region. Bennett did not immediately return a call for comment.
Councilwoman Brandy Williams said she wanted to know whether the proposed contract was competitively bid.
“The reason the laws were set up the way that they are was to prevent people from getting into office and then simply handing contracts to people. There’s usually a competitive bid process because, over time, citizens have seen that that could become an issue and it’s to prevent anything like that from happening,” she said.
“There’s at least a process that the public can see how the decision was made, the bids that came in, things of that nature, so there’s more transparency brought to the issue,” Williams added.
Williams said the YMCA looked into taking over some of the city’s pools the first time the city said it was looking for partners from the private sector. She said the YMCA concluded at that time that it wasn’t cost-effective.
“They didn’t even present the bid because in their due diligence process, the math didn’t work,” she said. “The difference (under this agreement) is that $600,000 in funds from the city. That’s the difference, and that begs the question: Could the Dessarts have used that $600,000 much like the Y is using it and ran the pools? Was that question asked?’
The YMCA of the Pikes Peak Region has been in the for 134 years.
“We believe this partnership with the city will enhance the overall quality of life and ease the burden of government,” Dan Dummermuth, president and CEO of the YMCA of the Pikes Peak Region, said in a statement.
“The YMCA strengthens the foundation of our community through youth development, healthy living and social responsibility,” he said.
According to the city, here are the highlights of the proposed agreement:
I don’t understand how this is anything more than the city subsidizing the YMCA. If the pools can’t be run at a profit and we’re going to pick up any shortfall, why even have a private company running the pools? The city could just run the pools and probably do it cheaper than paying YMCA employees to do the job. Very odd.
I think it’s a great idea.
City pools, profitable or not, benefit the community as a whole in the end. With pools closed, you are going to see more children not know how to swim, or choose to swim in areas that are unsafe.
I can’t imagine what my childhood would have been like without recreational services like city pools. Certainly kept me and many others out of trouble. Would you rather subsidize programs like this or pay more in police/court/jail costs?
Anyone else notice that this is a Christian group they are proposing take over the public pools? This contract should be competed and not hand delivered to the Y.
Why post a comment from an anonymous Council member who speculated that the Bach administration wanted to turn over the pools to the YMCA? Anyone can speculate. Name the Council member and tell us why they feel that way. Otherwise, it’s not relevant other than to show how petty some Council members are.
@Bryan Williams – It’s not odd, it’s cronyism. Were the Dessarts offered $600,000 to continue to run the pools? Mayor Bach is corrupt.
What was the hurry? The pools have been down for a while. Were there discussions about advertising for “RFPs(Requests for Proposals)? If not, Why not? Swimming at the Y has been prohibitively expensive for a while. How much will it cost to swim now? I’ll bet it doesn’t go down. What do you want to bet that the price will in fact go up and the Y will still claim they need every bit of the subsidy and cry that it wasn’t enough. This is that much more reason that the region should have all the parks, trails, open spaces and all related facilities under the umbrella of it’s own unique special taxing district, with it’s own oversight by a publicly elected board. It would be more transparent. It would not have to compete with other expenditures from the general fund. The amount of revenue generated would be directly proportional to the amount of citizen’s support. Board members would be directly responsible and accountable for their decisions. If they rule, thinking too much of themselves, we would at least have the chance to vote them out or cut their subsidy. The cost of going for a swim shouldn’t have to compete with whether there is enough money to set up the spy cameras for the night time brawlers down town.
Politics stinks sometimes! Whatever happened to being kind to your fellow man (& woman in this case). The Dessarts put their heart and souls into three of the city’s pools that had been closed down. They worked 24/7 to get them back in business…..cleaning, painting,furnishing, hiring employees, training staff and getting many acquatic programs started (not to mention all the $$$ they put into the business’. Both Kevin and Tina are very experienced in the business world, as well as in aquatics and were loving giving back to the community… what the city had given up on. Now, a new government body takes over and steps on little toes, because they can….ignoring all the hard work and efforts the Dessart family have put in to the Wilson Ranch Pool, Portal Pool and CS Rec. Center. Their work was finally beginning to pay off and they were seeing the light, until a selfish government body put them out. How sad (& cruel). Do you think that having the CEO of the YMCA on the Council had anything to do with it? The least they could have done was to permit the Dessarts to keep the Wilson Ranch and Portal Pools which were doing well (thanks to them) and let the Y take over the others. Sometimes greed and politics go hand in hand. Too bad.
There are a lot of companies out there that would have liked to bid on this contract. Just handing it to the YMCA is not the way this City should be run. Thanks goodness there are some (Congresswoman Williams) that are opposing or at least looking into this nepotism (for lack of a better comparison).
DO NOT allow the YMCA into City government without a competitive bid.
The city closed the pools because they couldn’t feasably fund the $1,000,000 subsidy they were spending to run them themselves but they can easily afford $600,000 to turn over facilities paid for by taxpayers to be managed by the YMCA.
Never mind the faithless and feckless attitude towards the city employees that will get the shaft, skipping the proposal process reeks of underhanded politics. Isn’t that why the last administration got thrown out on its ear? Sorry, rhetorical.
I too am in favor of the YMCA managing the pools. I believe that the urgency for the council to vote on this necessary so that the outdoor pools can be open for the entire summer season. Outdoor pools open Memorial Day weekend and close Labor Day. If the council accepts proposals these pools will remain closed another year. If the council votes in favor on April 5th the Y will have 7 weeks to hire and train staff and prepare the pools for the public. More than likely there will not be a loss of jobs, but rather the same people become Y employees instead of city employees.
The YMCA is a positive business entity in this community and the PPYMCA is considered one of the finest in the nation. The Y has had similar contracts with community pools in Falcon and Fountain that have been running smoothly for years. It should not matter if they are a Christian organization. They are not holding Bible study, they are simply trying to provide swim lessons and a service to our community. The Y upholds core values like honesty, respect and caring which is what all of the people in our community should have whether you are a person of faith or not.
The Y is offering to implement programs that they already have up and running efficiently. THEY ARE NOT ASKING TO MAKE A PROFIT! How is this greed? The city will have a hard time finding another managing company who is willing to do this and provide scholarship to low income families.
I think this is something that should be applauded. We have city government working efficiently with a high quality business to improve our community. I think it is ridiculous to associate underhanded politics with the opening of pools. This makes good business sense to me!
As a taxpayer I should not have to pay for the YMCA to operate their business! YMCA memberships and services are among the most expensive in the Springs! If this passes a monopoly will be created. If you want to swim in COS you have to join the YMCA! Transparency? Open Bid? Request For Proposals? Why not offer a fair opportunity to other businesses/investors? I am a frequent member at CCRC and would not have been informed if I missed the quick news clip. Why is this being pushed so fast? Just in time to interrupt planning, scheduling, and hiring for the current season with the existing open facilities. Please do it right!
I encourage all to research how the YMCA operated the community pool in Falcon. I believe it was Woodmen Hills…