City Desk ~ An insider’s view of the policies and politics of Colorado Springs city government

Archive for the 'VNI' Tag

Quote of the Week

January 27th, 2012, 11:02 pm by

Attorney Pat Mika, who represented 19-year-old Hooters waitress Illysa Medina after she was accused of serving a visibly intoxicated patron, said the CBI investigation of Metro VNI was nothing more than a whitewashing.

Mika said the investigation, which cleared the two undercover detectives involved in the case of wrongdoing, could not be classified as complete.

“They never talked to the victim of this false accusation and that is Illysa Medina. Nor they did they ever talk to the lawyer who represented her. They got nothing but self-serving information from the police officers who were there trying to preserve their careers, their reputations and their jobs.”

According to the CBI report, the only people interviewed were: VNI detectives Jeff True and Greg Young, police Sgt. Bret Poole, city prosecutors Elliot Fladen, Anthony Moore and Jarrett Benson, sheriff Bureau Chief Joe Breister, city spokesman John Leavitt and private attorney Vince Linden, who represented Hooters in front of the city’s liquor board.

 

Councilman: Hooters case factored into chief’s ouster

November 14th, 2011, 10:47 am by

Councilman Bernie Herpin

Before he retired, former police Chief Richard Myers said the controversial Hooters case had nothing to do with his departure.

“For those who have assumed that the controversy about a case at a local Hooter’s restaurant was responsible for my retirement, I can easily dismiss that one,” the chief wrote in his final Facebook post as head honcho at the Colorado Springs Police Department.

“Day in and day out, the Office of the Chief deals with so many sensitive issues, whether personnel related, crimes, public policy, fiscal….this one doesn’t even register on the Richter scale,” he wrote.

But City Councilman Bernie Herpin said the Hooters case was part of the reason that the chief lost his job.

“Based in part, on this incident, Colorado Springs Mayor (Steve Bach) asked our police chief to retire,” Herpin said in an email to Landon Miller, a California man who accused the Police Department of corruption after watching a story about the Hooters case on ABC’s 20/20.

Here is the full text of Herpin’s email to Miller:

Dear Mr. Miller,

Thank you for your email on the 20/20 story on the Hooters incident.

Based in part, on this incident, Colorado Springs Mayor asked our police chief to retire. And, as the 20/20 story stated, he has requested an investigation into the conduct of the liquor enforcement investigation of local businesses that serve alcohol. The task force that conducts these investigations, as is done in many cities, involves several different tactics, including using underaged confidential informants and undercover officers.

Like the Mayor, I am very concerned about how this case was handled and I support the Mayor’s call for an independent investigation.

However, to make a life changing decision on where to move your family based on a single incident does not seem to be very prudent to me. Colorado Springs is a great place to live and we are routinely listed near the top on many “best of” lists. The fact that our city administration took decisive action in this matter should reassure you that we do not tolerate inappropriate action by city employees. Our low taxes, clean air and water, great recreational opportunities, reasonable cost of living, and cultural venues make our community the destination of choice for many people and companies. For example, the Fortune 500 number 1 company, Walmart, is building a multimillion dollar data center here when they could have gone anywhere.

While, like Walmart, you apparently can move your family anywhere you want, I can assure you that you could do much worst than Colorado Springs and I would welcome you and your family to actually visit us and see first hand all that we have to offer.

Sincerely,

Bernie Herpin
Council Member District 4
City of Colorado Springs

Colorado Springs bashed after Hooters case hits 20/20

November 13th, 2011, 10:55 am by

Photo by Metro VNI

A California man who was “seriously considering” moving his family to the city of Colorado Springs said he changed his mind after watching a story about the botched Hooters case on ABC’s 20/20.

“I write tonight to congratulate Colorado Springs on your corrupt police force, as displayed on tonight’s episode of ’20/20,’” Landon Miller said Friday in an email to City Council members.

“To see sworn officers drinking on duty, and framing innocent restaurant employees, combined with the fact that the (City Attorney’s Office) prosecuted on such patently false evidence, shows that Colorado Springs is as corrupt a city as one might find,” he wrote.

City Councilwoman Lisa Czelatdko responded to Miller’s email.

Her response infuriated Miller.

“Councilmember Czelatdko’s reply is arrogant and personally insulting,” Miller said in an email to The Gazette.

“I appreciate that my message to the council members is blunt; however, to receive the council member’s response below was rather a shock.  One would think a public official would be rather more diplomatic, and would certainly not resort to insulting a potential resident, taxpayer, and voter of Colorado Springs,” he said.

Czelatdko accused the news media of getting the story wrong.

“Seemingly these days, all media stories presented are missing accuracy, truthfulness, and fairness,” said Czelatdko

“I think most people realize that when reading a paper or watching television, or they should,” she said.

Czelatdko has become leery of reporters after reports that she — according to her Facebook page — “pulled the city Councilmember card” to score concert tickets. Czelatdko later claimed she was being a smart-aleck.

The Gazette has written numerous stories about the police investigation against Hooters and waitress Illysa Medina. None of those stories has required a correction.

Here’s the email that Miller sent to City Council:

Good Evening,

I write tonight to congratulate Colorado Springs on your corrupt police force, as displayed on tonight’s episode of “20/20″.  To see sworn officers drinking on duty, and framing innocent restaurant employees, combined with the fact that the District Attorney prosecuted on such patently false evidence, shows that Colorado Springs is as corrupt a city as one might find.

The reason my opinion should matter to you, is that I am looking to relocate my family from Southern California.  Until tonight’s broadcast, Colorado Springs was one of three metropolitan areas I was seriously considering.  I will now never seriously consider Colorado Springs as a potential hometown.  Congratulations on allowing such corruption to flourish in your city.  I for one will now never visit, based upon what I saw tonight.

Sincerely,

Landon Miller

Here’s Czelatdko’s response to Miller:

Lisa Czelatdko

Mr. Miller,

Seemingly these days, all media stories presented are missing accuracy, truthfulness, and fairness. I think most people realize that when reading a paper or watching television, or they should. Our police department has many intelligent, committed, staff that protect this community and have the willingness to put their lives on the line dealing with individuals that choose to break the law, choose to harm others, choose to no longer care about this society.  Im assuming if Colorado Springs was one of your family’ s city choices it was because of the incredible weather, surrounding aesthetic beauty, top educational choices, and incomparably low property and utility taxes. Colorado Springs is a city of over 400,000 plus people and like any City, we have problems. A corrupt police force is not one of them.

Sincerely,
Lisa Czelatdko (sa-lot-ko)
District 3 City Councilmember
City of Colorado Springs

Here’s Miller’s response to Czelatdko, which he also sent to interim Police Chief Pete Carey, council members and The Gazette:

Good Day,

I live in Southern California, and am planning in the long-term to permanently move my family out of California.  Colorado Springs was one of the areas on my short list of possible relocation destinations, until I saw the ABC 20/20 segment last night about the Illysa Medina prosecution.  I grew admittedly angry at the Colorado Springs Police Department officers in the story, for their fraudulent account of the incident at Hooters.  In my anger, I searched last night for the CSPD Police Chief’s e-mail address, to share my disgust.  While I could not find his address, I found the e-mail address for all city council members on the city’s web site, and sent the council members a blunt message, which I enclose below, indicating the depth of my disgust at the behavior of the CSPD officers.

To my surprise, I received a response this morning from Lisa Czelatdko, District 3 City Councilmember.  Much of my surprise results from the fact that the response is not an auto-generated, “We’ve received your e-mail message” reply, but rather personally written and focused.  The remainder of my surprise results from the fact that Councilmember Czelatdko’s reply is arrogant and personally insulting.  I appreciate that my message to the council members is blunt; however, to receive the council member’s response below was rather a shock.  One would think a public official would be rather more diplomatic, and would certainly not resort to insulting a potential resident, taxpayer, and voter of Colorado Springs.

It is also noteworthy that Ms. Czelatdko copied her reply to all of her city council member peers, as well as Peter Carey, the interim CSPD police chief.

I read Daniel Chacon’s September 21st story this morning, which confirms my view, namely that the bringing of fraudulent charges by CSPD sworn officers is tolerated by CSPD leadership.  Indeed, Mr. Chacon’s article provides confirmation of this state of affairs, per the comments of CSPD spokesman Sgt. Steve Noblitt, and the referenced comments attributed to interim chief Carey.  It is shocking that a public official’s response to this state of affairs is so arrogantly unapologetic, and in fact was intentionally rude.

Landon Miller

Sodo Night Club could lose liquor license

October 31st, 2011, 12:34 pm by

Sodo Night Club on South Tejon Street is in danger of losing its liquor license.

Representatives for Sodo have been summoned to appear before the city’s liquor board Friday for a suspension and revocation hearing.

Sodo is accused of allowing a customer remove “an unsealed alcohol container from the licensed premises” on June 11.

An employee of the club is also accused of “intentionally, knowingly or recklessly” giving police “false or misleading information” that night, according to an order to show cause and notice of hearing.

The order to show cause doesn’t provide any more information about the alleged liquor code violations.

The liquor board meeting, which starts at 9 a.m., is on the third floor of City Hall, 107 N. Nevada Ave.

The Redd Horse, a bar on South Academy Boulevard, is also in jeopardy of losing its liquor license.

The Redd Horse is accused of selling alcohol to an underage confidential informant on June 4, according to city documents.

 

Quote of the Day

October 19th, 2011, 4:17 pm by

“The City initially denied fulfilling the (Colorado Open Records Act) request on the basis that the email communications were protected communications that involved attorney work product, and might reveal legal strategies and tactics used in similar prosecutions.  Because the emails were later required to be provided by the City Attorney’s Office to opposing counsel in a different prosecution, the protection on those two emails was waived and they are now being released pursuant to CORA.”

— Chief Communications Officer Cindy Aubrey said today about the city’s decision to release the emails in the botched Hooters case despite the city’s initial refusal.


Police chief says Hooters case didn’t lead to ‘retirement’

October 11th, 2011, 3:43 pm by

Police Chief Richard Myers said the controversy surrounding the recent Hooters investigation had nothing  to do with his ouster … I mean … retirement.

“For those who have assumed that the controversy about a case at a local Hooter’s restaurant was responsible for my retirement, I can easily dismiss that one,” the chief wrote in his final Facebook post as head honcho at the Colorado Springs Police Department.

“Day in and day out, the Office of the Chief deals with so many sensitive issues, whether personnel related, crimes, public policy, fiscal….this one doesn’t even register on the Richter scale,” he wrote.

Here is the full text of the chief’s post:

Mark Twain once observed, “If you don’t read the newspaper, you’re uninformed.  If you read the newspaper, you’re mis-informed.”  Such has certainly been the case surrounding many of the events at CSPD.  As we’ve written about here before, as a responsible public agency, we work within both legal and self-imposed constraints that serve to ensure we are accurate, factual, and relevant with the information we share.  Often, that leads to some delays so that we can be sure our information IS factual and not conjecture, or that a family is notified before we release sensitive information, or that what may seem like related incidents are, in fact, unrelated.  And, sometimes we believe in preserving the privacy rights of citizens, employees, victims, etc and do not release some information.   Whenever there is a vacuum, it is natural that some will try to fill it in.  Unfortunately, that only adds to “misinformation.”

As I write my final Facebook article, I want to at least correct a couple of misinformation things that keep lingering.  First, for those who have assumed that the controversy about a case at a local Hooter’s restaurant was responsible for my retirement, I can easily dismiss that one.  Day in and day out, the Office of the Chief deals with so many sensitive issues, whether personnel related, crimes, public policy, fiscal….this one doesn’t even register on the Richter scale.  Any CEO who would change leadership every time there is a little controversy would burn through a whole lot of police chiefs…..

Secondly, those who promoted an image of drunken cops gone wild at Hooters are simply using this to play out their own bias against the police.  Was anyone else disappointed about the repeated attacks on undercover cops and alcohol without any attempt to study and learn what the actual policy is, what major city police agencies across the country do, what our own state liquor enforcement unit does, and if the officers being discredited in this matter were within or outside of said policy?  Alas, sometimes the facts just get in the way of a good story.   I wish the one, lone CSPD officer and the single El Paso County deputy who together are responsible for all liquor code enforcement for the over 800 licensed premises throughout Colorado Springs and El Paso County much luck as they try to carry out an impossible mission while having to justify their necessity.

There is and always will be a tension between police and the people who report the news.  Most of my professional experience as a chief in four states since 1984 has included healthy, respectful, and mutually beneficial dialogue between the media and the police.  I have made transparency a key priority for CSPD in my time here.  I’m grateful that the majority of our media counterparts have recognized and appreciated our increased efforts, and I’m also very impressed with the response from you all, our Facebook community, in your hunger for information directly from us.  Help support the CSPD Facebook page with your questions, your ideas, and especially your presence.

Finally, thank you for the honor and privilege of serving as your police chief.

Poll: Readers demand release of secret emails in Hooters case

October 11th, 2011, 9:52 am by

An overwhelming majority of respondents in an online poll think the city of Colorado Springs should release the emails between a city prosecutor and a police detective involved in the botched Hooters case.

Of the 200 votes cast so far, 91 percent say the public has a right to know what’s in the emails.

“Share the Emails! Sunlight is good for freedom,” caribou11 wrote in a comment that has generated 35 votes up and 3 votes down.

The city rejected an open-records request for emails between Assistant City Attorney Elliot Fladen and Detective Jeff True of the Metro Vice, Narcotics and Intelligence Division.

Cindy Aubrey, chief communications officer for Mayor Steve Bach, said releasing the emails would be “contrary to (the) public interest.”

“The CORA request is being denied because our attorneys believe that releasing the requested document would compromise how our attorneys prepare for prosecution, including disclosing strategies and information that would hurt future cases,” Aubrey said last month.

Most readers who have commented on gazette.com seem to disagree with the city’s reasoning.

“What is contrary to the public’s interest is the city covering up this fiasco,” wrote billthecat.

“Lies were told. This has been confirmed many times and ways. The city is hiding the proof that these cops were dirty and the dirt is rising all the way to the top,” billthecat wrote. “The more the city tries to hide things, the less credible they become.”

Billthecat’s comment has generated 34 votes up and 3 votes down.

Pictures from undercover Hooters bust revealed

September 29th, 2011, 3:51 pm by

When questions about a VNI investigation against Hooters and one of its waitresses first surfaced, The Gazette requested, among other things, all photographic material in the case.

The Colorado Springs Police Department complied, providing two grainy black-and-white photos taken by detectives during their undercover sting June 23.

Since the photos were difficult to make out, the newspaper requested color copies, which the department provided today.

The photos were used to support the charges against the restaurant and waitress Illysa Medina, who were accused of serving a visibly intoxicated patron. Those charges have since been dismissed.

One of the photos shows Medina’s backside as she’s standing next to the man who was allegedly intoxicated.

The other photos shows the allegedly intoxicated man about to take a drink of what appears to be beer.

That photo also shows what appears to be half-empty glasses of beer on the table where the detectives were sitting.

CLICK ON THE PHOTOS TO GET A CLOSER LOOK.

More on the case:

In June, two detectives with the Metro Vice, Narcotics and Intelligence Division went to Hooters at The Citadel mall to conduct an undercover sting with an underage confidential informant. Even though Hooters didn’t serve alcohol to the minor, the detectives sat down at a table with their informant and ordered lunch and beer.

According to police reports, the detectives said they witnessed a Hooters waitress serve a visibly intoxicated patron, which violates the liquor code. One of the detectives also said he reported seeing the patron stagger and use table chairs for balance when he walked by their table.

The detectives, through the City Attorney’s Office, brought a case against Hooters and the waitress for serving a visibly intoxicated patron. But both cases were dismissed after Hooters produced a surveillance videotape that called the detective’s assertions into question.

Last week, Mayor Steve Bach called for an investigation of VNI.